piplover: (Default)
piplover ([personal profile] piplover) wrote2009-03-11 07:24 pm

Bwah?

Have you ever been reading a really good fic, good plot, well written, when all the sudden it goes off into WTF-land?  Yeah, that's where I'm at now.  I can't even stop reading it because it sucked me in and now I have to find out how it ends.  But - where did that great story go? 
dreamflower: gandalf at bag end (Default)

[personal profile] dreamflower 2009-03-12 01:18 pm (UTC)(link)
I know. I recently totally went off another WIP I'd been following because of an unwarned character death, and even though it was an OC, it still really upset me. So far as I could tell there was no good reason except to make the canon character suffer.

There has to be more reason to it than that. The first time I killed off a character, I agonized over it for months, before I finally realized it was necessary. And I went out of my way to warn people. I telegraphed it in every way imaginable, so no one would be shocked. And I put it in a side story, and not in my main WIP at the time, so readers who did not want to read about it would not have to.